In the April issue of RINA Systems' Performance Update:
Feature Highlight – Exporting Data Files from Portfolio Graphs
Strategies Updated – CBO & BBO Strategies Are Updated through February
New Information – Sneak Preview at our Upcoming Product Releases
Offers – Pre-Release Purchase and Upgrade pricing now available
Feature Highlight -
Did you know that starting in PortfolioStream 5 and
Portfolio Evaluator 7 users are able to export any performance data that appears on a chart to text files for external use? Previously exports were limited to
the equity curve or reports. This new feature can be useful if you would like to reproduce chart data in other applications, such as Excel, for additional graphing
or analysis. To save the data simply select the disk icon on the graphs toolbar (the tool tip reads Save Chart Data) and select the directory and name of the file
you wish to save. This was one of the many improvements to the graphs that were implemented in PortfolioStream 5
and Portfolio Evaluator 7.
Strategies Updated -
We have been running several portfolios derived from 2 trading strategies and multiple parameters (specifically 3 parameters for each strategy) over the last few
years. The purpose was to take a well-documented trading strategy from published literature (in our case Perry Kaufman’s Trading Systems and Methods) and follow
it going forward using PortfolioStream 5. We recently updated the strategies and report on their
recent performance below. We last updated the strategies through August 2004 so our test will cover the September 2004 through February (18th) 2005, as well as
starting dates of October 2003(when we first began tracking), and October 1995 (the beginning date for the original backtest). The tests were conducted using
PortfolioStream 5 and TradeStation 8 on the same set of North American futures markets used in the
previous test described in the previous Performance Update for October, 2004.
The strategies all yielded poor performance in varying degrees
since August 2004 (Displayed in Figure 1). Interestingly the strategies that used channels based on standard deviation bands as the entry and exit signals in
general did worse than those that used simple N period highs and lows for purposes of creating the channels. Figure 2 shows the equity curve of various strategy
parameters over the August 2004 through February 2005 period.
Figure 1 - Results since August 2004
Parameter
Total Return
Average Trade
Number Trades
Max DD
Profit Factor
BBO 40
($229,882.42)
($7,934.09)
52
$757,293.75
0.52
BBO 60
($298,376.98)
($14,138.58)
34
$688,213.60
0.36
CBO 40
($99,480.225)
($13,967.89)
36
$565,002.20
0.36
CBO 80
$44,309.300
($20,549.17)
9
$480,487.45
0.23
Figure 2 - Performance Since September 2004
Looking back a little further, we
originally reviewed these strategies in Performance Update for October, 2003.
Figure 3 displays the equity curves of 2 of the
parameters for the channel breakout (CBO) strategies (40 and 80 period lookback) since
October, 2003. Over this lookback, arguably the fairest period period for establishing "out-of-sample" results, the results have also been
poor. We believe one can reasonably assume that a trader who implemented these or comparable strategies (intermediate to long term trend
following on a basket of diversified North American futures) would likely have suffered losses, possibly extreme, over that period.
Figure 3 - Performance from October 2003
Figure 4 - Performance from October 1995
Reviewing these hypothetical
portfolios recent results draws our attention to how sensitive historical models are to the starting date of the study. The
figure above displays the whole period performance, including "in-sample" data over which the strategies were originally tested.
While the overall strategies appear to be profitable, we see that from the moment the strategies were tracked they have suffered
poor performance. Moreover, the trader starting in the out-of-sample period in 2003 would not have the benefit of having the
subsequent drawdown mitigated by previous accumulated gains that occurred from 1995 through 2003. Of course finding strategies
that will perform well in the future, whose results were not random or will be competed away by their previous success and/or
popularity as other traders adopt them, is one of the primary tasks of the trader/systems analyst. It will be interesting to
see in future updates if the recent failures were cyclical, or indicative of model that has either failed or was the result of
too much hindsight in the first place.
Future Updates - While
no tool can remove the risk of strategies performing poorly in the future, we are designing a tool to help mitigate the impact of
using too much hindsight in market selection. Our next major release of
PortfolioStream, version 6, will have the ability to split a historical study into two sub-periods and after making market
selections based on performance in the "in-sample" period, it will simulate trading the of the selected markets going forward. While
this may not be the antidote to one of the many possible causes for the results of the strategies tracked in the Performance Update,
which in fact may not even be a fundamentally profitable approach, it will be another tool at the disposal of researchers especially
with regards to market selection. Is it better to build a portfolio from markets that test well with the system over some period, or
with a much broader basket of markets regardless of individual system/market performance? This is what we intend to test (using the
same studies) in forthcoming editions of Performance Update.
New Information - Sneak Preview at our Upcoming Product Releases
Currently the latest and most powerful versions of our award
winning Performance Suite and
PortfolioStream applications are being developed. As the development of the new features near completion we would like to give our
customers a small glimpse into some of the features that will be in the forthcoming release of these applications:
"In-Sample / Out-of-Sample" Portfolio Selection –
users will be able to automate the splitting of portfolios into a sample over which the portfolio components are selected from a larger basket
based on performance criteria, and a forward "blind testing" period where prospective returns for that selected portfolio are calculated. This
feature helps system testers reduce the amount of “fitting” that occurs when selecting markets and systems for a portfolio.
Global setting of Margin and Sectors for a
database – Many users are aware of our exposure and margin usage graphs that let system testers see how much capital their strategies were
using over time. Now you can set the margin for a symbol root (ES for e-mini S&P for example) across all portfolios in the database. This will
save you substantial time when setting up portfolio margins. In addition, we have added the ability for equities to set the margin to be equal
a percent of the share price. Thus if a share of MSFT is 25 and the user would like the initial margin to be equal to 50 percent of the share
price, this percentage can be expressed mathematically to establish margins for all stocks in the portfolio.
Save Summary Returns – Use the feature
to save off high-level calculated results to a separate database helping you to better organize calculated portfolio results. This reduces the
time necessary to access an already calculated result while at the same time providing a central repository for previously generated portfolio
results. This is important because over time a typical PortfolioStream user
can accumulate many databases of studies and it’s convenient and efficient to consolidate the high-level performance results of disparate
studies into one location (database) versus searching through many files.
We will publish additional features on our
website when we announce the exact release date. The estimated release data is May 1, 2005 (subject to change).
Offers - Pre-Release Purchase and Upgrade pricing now available
We are now accepting pre-release orders for
the PortfolioStream 6 - purchase and upgrade options. $1000 OFF -
New customers may purchase PortfolioStream 6 for the special pre-release sale price of $3,995 (regularly $4,995). $300 OFF - Existing users of PortfolioStream who upgrade to version 6
(from version 5) can do so for the reduced price of $695 (regularly $995). To receive this savings mention the sale code - 282635 and the
savings will be applied towards your purchase. This offer will be valid through May 15, 2005 - at which time the cost will be the standard upgrade
pricing. As a service to our clients we always provide access to one year worth of new releases for free from the date of purchase. To read
more information from RINA Systems' Testimonials page click
HERE. If you would like to contact RINA Systems, Inc. you may do so via phone at
(513)-469-7462, via fax at (513)-469-2223, or via e-mail at info@rinasystems.com
The purpose of the Performance Update newsletter is to
offer ideas and educational samples of strategies through the use of RINA Systems software applications. The strategies described in the Performance
Update newsletter are not intended to be used as actual trading strategies, but are included for educational purposes only. No offer or solicitation
to buy or sell securities, commodities or securities derivative products of any kind, or any type of trading or investment advice, recommendation or
strategy, is made, given or in any manner provided by RINA Systems or any of its affiliates. If such advice is sought, the services of a licensed
professional should be obtained. Past performance, whether actual or indicated by historical, simulated tests of strategies, is no guarantee of
future performance or success. Hypothetical or simulated performance results have certain limitations. Unlike an actual performance record simulations
do not represent actual trading. Also since the trades have not actually been executed the results may have under - or over - compensated for the
impact if any, of certain market factors such as liquidity. Simulated trading programs in general are also subject to the fact that they are designed
with the benefit of hindsight. No representation is being made that any account will or is likely to achieve profits or losses similar to those shown.
There is a significant risk of loss involved in futures and securities trading. RINA Systems, Inc. will not be responsible for any losses or lost
profits resulting from investment decisions based on any RINA Systems product or service information obtained through use of any RINA Systems product
or service or otherwise. TradeStation® and EasyLanguage® are registered trademarks of TradeStation Technologies, Inc.